2024 – White Sox (Chris Mayle) defeat Astros (Bruce Fryer) 4-2
2024 – Orioles (Scott Berger) defeat Dodgers (James Farris), 4-2
2023 – Braves (Mark Wenzel) defeat Rays (Rob Turchetta), 4-1
2022 – Rays (Rob Turchetta) defeat Dodgers (James Farris), 4-2
2021 – Dodgers (James Farris) defeat Rays (Rob Turchetta), 4-1
2020 – Dodgers (James Farris) defeat Expos (Brian Adams), 4-1
2019 – Tigers (Dave Cromer) defeat Cardinals (John Duff), 4-2
2018 – Astros (Bruce Fryer) defeat Rays (Rob Turchetta), 4-3
2017 – Dodgers (James Farris) defeat Cubs (Eric Adams), 4-2
2016 – Orioles (Scott Berger) defeat Dodgers (James Farris), 4-3
2015 – White Sox (Chris Mayle) defeat Tigers (Dave Cromer), 4-1
2014 – White Sox (Chris Mayle) defeat Giants (Todd Findley), 4-3
2013 – White Sox (Chris Mayle) defeat Orioles (Scott Berger), 4-0
2012 – Giants (Todd Findley) defeat Blue Jays (Don Adams), 4-0
2011 – Orioles (Scott Berger) defeat Astros (Bruce Fryer), 4-0
2010 – Athletics (Dave Johnston) defeat Red Sox (Stan Berger), 4-2
2009 – Expos (Brian Adams) defeat Cardinals (John Duff), 4-2
2008 – Athletics (Dave Johnston) defeat Orioles (Scott Berger), 4-3
2007 – Devil Rays (Rob Turchetta) defeat Blue Jays (Don Adams), 4-2
2006 – Royals (Ed Haney) defeat Twins (Bruce Byers), 4-2
2005 – Giants (Todd Findley) defeat Twins (Bruce Byers), 4-3
2004 – White Sox (Chris Mayle) defeat Reds (Whitney Byers)
2003 – Twins (Bruce Byers) defeat Giants (Todd Findley), 4-3
2002 – Giants (Todd Findley) defeat Rockies (Dan Klink), 4-2
2001 – Giants (Todd Findley) defeat Rockies (Dan Klink), 4-1
2000 – Cardinals (John Duff) defeat Orioles (Scott Berger), 4-2
1999 – Pirates (John Solvey) defeat Indians (Chris Heap), 4-2
1998 – Orioles (Scott Berger) defeat Pirates (John Solvey), 4-3
1997 – Royals (Ed Haney) defeat Orioles (Scott Berger), 4-3
1996 – Orioles (Scott Berger) defeat Reds (Whitney Byers), 4-3
1995 – Orioles (Scott Berger) defeat Padres (Rick Westfall), 4-2
1994 – Blue Jays (Chris Burton) defeat Tigers (Dwight Conlan)
1993 – Orioles (Scott Berger) defeat Reds (Whitney Byers), 4-0
1992 – Blue Jays (Chris Burton) defeat Pirates (John Solvey), 4-0
1991 – Blue Jays (Chris Burton) – unknown opponent
1990 – Blue Jays (Chris Burton) defeat Twins (Bruce Byers), 4-1
1989 – Mets (Stan Berger) defeat Tigers (Dwight Conlan), 4-1
1988 – Tigers (Dwight Conlan) defeat Blue Jays (Chris Burton), 4-1